Commentary: The Racetrack, A Changing Perspective
by: Equine Disease Quarterly
January 20 2009, Article # 13479
Recently a veterinary colleague remarked that a horse that had sustained a minor laceration in the starting gate had been scratched. While there was no expectation that the horse's performance would be impacted, she could not justify permitting an injured horse to race. If the same incident had occurred several years earlier, it is unlikely she would have recommended the scratch. This incident illustrates a philosophical shift that has occurred in horse racing and the resulting requirement that we defend why a horse races rather than why it doesn't.
Subtly and over time, a critical question for this industry has evolved from "can a horse race with a medical condition?" to "should a horse race with a medical condition?" The next question looming on the horizon is "should a horse race that has had a medical condition in the past?" The ground is shifting beneath our feet as we as veterinarians and the horse racing industry try to answer these questions to the satisfaction of the public and personal conscience.
Veterinary medical progress has enhanced our diagnostic capabilities in the detection of minor injuries and has afforded recovery from numerous major injuries previously considered life-threatening. Factor in our understanding of the cumulative nature of catastrophic injuries--that these injuries develop over time and perhaps without any clinical signs--and it becomes difficult to know with any degree of certainty what the responsible course is. Will an argument be put forth that if a horse has been injured in any capacity it should never race again?
Some horses sustain injuries, recover, and return to competition; others don't. Of the horses that return to competition, some compete successfully; some don't. But what of the horses not injured? Some compete successfully; some don't. They are all individuals, and they respond best when treated that way. Thoughtful, ethical, responsible decisions on a case-by-case basis should be the standard.
When I first started working as a racetrack regulatory veterinarian, "racing soundness" was defined as the ability of a horse to complete a race. This was a difficult concept, as racing soundness could not be identified until after a race. Raised eyebrows at the pre-race exam were typically met with the trainer's exhortation, "Don't worry, Doc. This horse'll win." And even when the winner did limp into the Winner's Circle, the horse had just proved its ability to compete successfully and retained its classification as "racing sound." Racing soundness was associated with the ability of a horse to perform to expectations rather than with the actual health or welfare of the animal. Risk management was directed at the bettor and not the horse.
Times have clearly changed. The definition of racing soundness is now predicated on equine health, safety, and welfare. The health of horse racing is directly tied to the health of the horses. Every industry stakeholder has an incentive to identify and engage in practices that promote responsible stewardship of the racehorse. The industry has been engaged in some critical self-evaluation, and change is being embraced. The traditions of racing have collided with the frontiers of science, and the horse is the ultimate beneficiary.
Many changes in horse racing have occurred in the last 20 years--much of which I could not have foreseen, but little that I regret. The challenges facing this industry are as great as the opportunities. I do know that my decision to be a part of this grand sport was, pardon the pun, a sound one.
3 comments:
너무오랜세월의시간 무관한영어,언젠가 날잡아 종로번역사무실에 맞겨볼까 생각을 합니다만,..노마드님 요점이 뭡니까^^...
최근에 어느경마장의 경주에서 한마필이
스타팅게이트에서 사소한 상처를 입은바
수의재결이 말의 복지와 안녕을 위해(!!)
말을 경주에서 제외했다는애긴데,
이게 예전에는 경주에 지장이없는경우라고판단되면 그대로 경주진행을 했는데
이제는 말과 경주에 대한 인식이 바뀌어
그야말로 말의 복지를 위해 (!)
사소하나마 말의 건전성과 건전성을 전제로하는 경주의 전개를 위해
이러한 용인이 통요퇴지 않을 것 같은
변화의 바람이 분다는 얘기입습죠,...^^
노마드님의댓글에 응답이 늦은감이,,,,,경마일이 또왔군요,될수있으면 즐거운날들이 올해에도,앞으로도 지속되었으면하는 마음으로요 .....색다른 느낌이있는 하루가 되었으면 좋겠군여~ 그것이 무엇이든지든간에...
Post a Comment